Attawapiskat didn’t Mismanage Funds, Harper — You Did

This is reposted from the Huffington Post. It is written by  Hon. Carolyn Bennett. She is a Liberal MP.

The only comment that I would like to make is that our PM Harper, in attacking the Native peoples, he seems bent on throwing himself against a rock that will end up breaking him. He is not use to confronting a people that refuses to be silent and go away. He is only used to dictating to the rest of Canadians that lie down give away their rights and freedoms. (End of comment).

Carolyn BennettThe government was wrong in its response to the crisis in Attawapiskat and its ongoing attempt to divide Canadians with misleading information is shameful. Federal court ruled
this morning the that the Conservative government’s response to the crisis in Attawapiskat was unreasonable and failed to look at any remedy other than the appointment of a Third Party Manager.

Rather that own up to their mistake the Conservative government says it is “disappointed” with the decision. What will it take for this government to take responsibility for its own incompetence?

The court made it clear that Attawapiskat did not mismanage funds, as the Conservatives — from the Prime Minister on down — accused them of doing in an attempt to deflect blame from themselves. It also made clear that the decision to appoint a third party manager during the Attawapiskat crisis was unreasonable. But this is part of a much broader issue.

At the outset, the government knew putting a third party manager in place was the wrong direction to go in. The government’s own 2010 review of its intervention policy, which they introduced back in 2006, found that the use of Third Party Management was neither cost effective, nor did it manage to achieve its stated objectives, such as improving conditions in First Nations communities.

In fact, because third party managers are paid out of First Nations community funding, the process was found to simply drain the very limited capacity in these communities without dealing with the underlying issues that led to intervention being considered in the first place.

The review noted that third party managers do not generally contribute to capacity building and that there are a number of unintended impacts of the policy. Most notably, the policy has a negative impact on the availability of band support funding for governance and administration and the cost of co-managers and third party managers is particularly high for smaller and more remote communities.

The previous federal minister, Chuck Strahl, promised to overhaul the intervention policy back in the summer of 2010, but we have unfortunately seen no action on this commitment.

Further, the government’s own August 2010 audit of on reserve housing showed that funding is based on bad data and that the government cannot adequately demonstrate the extent to which funding for housing achieves expected outcomes. The government’s own assessments of its policy for intervention and its programs for housing showed they were abysmal failures.

Yet, the Prime Minister made a political decision to distract Canadians from his government’s neglect by blaming the victim. Harper purposely called attention to large aggregate funding numbers for the community, quoting money spent over many years and amalgamating money for programs like health, education and various other social programs most Canadians take for granted. His attempt to divert Canadians with this “sticker shock” created the impression that the community was well funded and the band must have squandered or misused money.

Shamefully, this was the cornerstone of the government’s response to the court decision today. Repeating the misleading figure of $90-million, the government is continuing its campaign of confusion in an attempt to convince Canadians that First Nations are getting large sums of money and that the government is fulfilling its obligations.

This is an impression that has now been established to be unfounded by the federal court. Despite the government’s comments about management, they failed to produce any evidence of mismanagement or incorrect spending by the band. Further, the court noted that the $90-million referenced by the Prime Minister, and government spokespeople even today, could not have related exclusively to the funds made available for housing repair or reconstruction.

It is clear that this government sees Aboriginal people as adversaries. It chose to smear the reputation of the band instead of owning up to its responsibility to respond to the housing emergency in Attawapiskat.

Given today’s court decision, the Conservative government should accept responsibility for its own mismanagement of the crisis, abstain from an appeal and reimburse the Attawapiskat band for all funds they were forced to pay for this third party manager. We also need a complete overhaul of the government’s intervention policy so that it is focused on partnership and collaboration and deals with issues like capacity development and prevention strategies.

The Conservative government must work with First Nations to find solutions rather than simply trying to deflect blame for their own failures. (End of Article.)

Where Harper First Learned His Parliamentary Skills ( a spoof)


About pushinback

Back in 1993, I attended an anti-Nafta rally in Ottawa along with over 110,000 others. But despite the overwhelming opposition to NAFTA, the steamroller rolled on. It was there that I came to understand the one vital thing that I have been preaching ever since. There are so many issues, and so many fighting each issue, we are all spinning our wheels, and wasting our time, talents and energy, because each election, we give the politicians our power and so the deck is stacked against us. I said it that day and I say it with more fervency today. We all have one issue that we share, and we should all stop fighting for our own issues and losing anyways, and we should fight to achieve that one thing that we all share. We Canadians all have to fight to finally get a say between elections. We need to fight to make politicians accountable to us, the people. If there is no accountability, and the people have no say between elections, we have no Democracy. My Blog is written to teach the reader the essential knowledge of freedom and Democracy. Please read, and learn. I am one person, but I leave you my witness that one person is not powerless, only first you must first learn and then act. Let the democratic revolution begin. Kindest regards, Rob McQueen
This entry was posted in Idle No More and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s